| The Tiger Williams Trophy is an annual award given to the ASHL's top entertainer or ruffian. |
 |
| Season |
Winner |
| 1 |
Scott Stevens (MOO) |
| 2 |
Marty McSorley (SUS) |
| 3 |
Kevin Stevens (SHI) |
| 4 |
Joey Kocur (SOU) |
| 5 |
Scott Stevens (TIG) |
| 6 |
Dave Manson (HAM) |
| 7 |
Tony Twist (TIG) |
| 8 |
Alexander Karpovtsev (WHO) |
|